The private life will not suit US department stores

News
 |  
Sep 2024
 |  
Financial Times
Save to favorites
Your item is now saved. It can take a few minutes to sync into your saved list.

What: Major US department store chains are exploring privatization and mergers to combat falling revenues and adapt to changing retail landscapes.

Why it is important: The trend underscores the mounting pressure on traditional retail models, highlighting the necessity for radical transformation in operations, customer engagement, and business structures to remain viable in the modern retail environment.

The US department store sector is undergoing significant changes as major players seek to reinvent themselves in a challenging retail environment. Nordstrom's founding family has partnered with a Mexican retailer to take the company private, aiming to focus on fixing its retail business without the pressures of quarterly earnings reports. Similarly, Macy's has faced repeated acquisition attempts from Arkhouse Management and Brigade Capital Management, while struggling with declining sales and profitability.

These moves reflect a broader trend in the industry, with department stores' market share plummeting from 14% of total retail sales in 1993 to less than 3% today. The sector faces intense competition from luxury retailers, discount chains like TJ Maxx, and the rise of e-commerce. Some companies, like Sears and JCPenney, have already gone through bankruptcy and re-emerged under private ownership.

Consolidation is also reshaping the landscape, as evidenced by Hudson's Bay Company's acquisition of Neiman Marcus to merge with Saks Fifth Avenue. This trend towards privatization and mergers is driven by the need to streamline operations, reduce costs, and gain more flexibility to adapt to changing consumer preferences.

Despite these efforts, department stores continue to face significant challenges. They struggle to differentiate themselves and are squeezed between luxury and discount retailers. The shift towards online shopping and direct-to-consumer sales by brands further complicates their position. As these retailers navigate this difficult terrain, the future of the traditional department store model remains uncertain.

IADS Notes: The US department store landscape is undergoing significant changes, driven by financial pressures and evolving consumer behaviours. Nordstrom's attempts to go private, led by the founding family, reflect a desire for greater operational flexibility without public market scrutiny . Meanwhile, Macy's faces substantial challenges, implementing a major restructuring plan that includes closing 150 stores over three years amidst declining sales and profitability . These individual company struggles are symptomatic of broader industry trends, with department stores' market share plummeting from 14% of total retail sales in 1993 to less than 3% today . In response to these pressures, the industry is seeing consolidation, exemplified by Hudson's Bay Company's acquisition of Neiman Marcus Group to merge with Saks Fifth Avenue, aiming to create synergies and boost competitiveness in the luxury retail market.


The private life will not suit US department stores